Nirmal

What is the relationship between primary turnout and general election outcomes?

by Nirmal  ::  Filed Under Elections 2008  ::  February 27th, 2008 @ 7:34 am EST

(originally posted at nirmalm.com)

We’ve often heard the argument that because Democratic primary participation is disproportionately higher in a particular state, Democrats stand a chance of performing better in that state in the general election. After Alex Thurston made this argument about the upcoming Oklahoma Senate race, I decided to find out if this claim is actually true.

To validate this argument, we want to compare the percentage Democratic primary turnout (out of the total primary turnout) to the performance of the Democratic presidential candidate in the general election for each state. To account for crossover voters, it makes sense to only consider state primaries that were competitive on both sides. For simplicity’s sake I decided to look at the 2000 election, but the 1988 election would work as well. Data and full details on how I selected the states here.

Here are the states with competitive primaries:

Clearly, in 2000 there was a correlation between partisan turnout in competitive primaries and the general election outcome in those states. A linear regression with 2000 Gore performance as the dependent variable has an R-Squared value of .829 and a p-value less than 0.001, which indicates that there is a strong linear relationship.Given that, this year’s primary turnout in states that were competitive on both sides may be a useful input when determining which states are going to be “swing states” in the general election.Another argument, that Democrats will do better in the upcoming general election because Democratic primary turnout is higher nationally this year than in previous years, is harder to validate. As Matt Stoller pointed out, this is because there have been too few competitive primaries on both sides since the McGovern reforms to begin making that judgment. Once we know the 2008 general election results, we can start to think about this by examining the turnout in competitive primaries in 1988, 2000, and 2008.

Nirmal is an activist from Michigan who has worked with a variety of progressive organizations and campaigns. His writing can be found at nirmalm.com

The Seminal News Feed

Jordan's king urges Israel to avoid Gaza invasion
Thursday, 20 November 2008, 3:52 pm
AMMAN, Nov 20 (Reuters) - Jordan's King Abdullah warned Israeli leaders this week that a military offensive in Gaza would destabilise the region, a Jordanian political source said Thursday.

IRAQ WRAPUP 1-Iraqi PM says US pact will restore sovereignty
Thursday, 20 November 2008, 3:50 pm
BAGHDAD, Nov 20 (Reuters) - A pact allowing U.S. troops to stay in Iraq three more years is Iraq's best option for restoring sovereignty, and its critics are making unrealistic demands, Prime Minister. […]

ICC prosecutor seeks arrest of Darfur rebels
Thursday, 20 November 2008, 3:38 pm
AMSTERDAM, Nov 20 (Reuters) - The International Criminal Court prosecutor requested arrest warrants on Thursday for rebels in Sudan's Darfur region, accusing them of storming an African Union camp and. […]


LEAVE A COMMENT

Join the discussion! Get started by reading our Comment Policies.
YOUR COMMENT   (simple HTML is allowed)   Click to quote selected text
       

Take the Blog Reader Project survey.

UPCOMING ON REDDIT
Please vote!

UPCOMING ON DIGG
Please vote!
I support Health Care for America Now