Alex Thurston

McCain in Iraq

by Alex Thurston  ::  Filed Under Middle East / South Asia  ::  March 16th, 2008 @ 12:44 pm EST

As John McCain (Opportunist-AZ) conducts his eighth trip to Iraq since 2003, a number of voices are questioning the senator’s integrity.

With Lieberman and Lindsey Graham in tow, McCain hopes, Reuters says, “to project himself as a world leader while Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama fight out a bitter Democratic nomination process at home.” After Iraq, he will meet with Israeli, Jordanian, French, and British leaders.

While acknowledging that world leaders like British Prime Minister Gordon Brown and French President Nicolas Sarkozy might see the trip as a chance to size him up as a potential president, McCain has said he is not traveling as a candidate.

Not traveling as a candidate, eh? Sure…except for the fundraisers, where bigwigs in London will pay upwards of $1000 a plate to share a meal with the senator.

And going to Iraq is inherently political. Could Obama or Clinton get away with claiming that a trip to Iraq or Israel was apolitical? McCain’s trip, as noted above, is meant to project the image that he understands the hard realities of the occupation - that only he has the sober decision-making ability to “win.”

Unfortunately for McCain, that image fell apart long ago.

Sen. John McCain is well-known for scorching denunciations of Democrats, who he says would raise the “white flag of surrender” by cutting off funds for U.S. troops in Iraq.

But 15 years ago, it was McCain himself who startled colleagues by proposing to cut off money for a struggling and embattled U.S. force in another perilous place: Somalia.

On the campaign trail today, McCain is seen as an unyielding hawk. But before his first presidential run in 2000, he declared he would work with the Democratic Party’s brain trust to devise his foreign policy.

And while he now describes himself as a “foot soldier in the Reagan revolution,” he infuriated Republicans as a freshman congressman in 1983 by trying to thwart President Reagan’s deployment of troops in Lebanon.

The presumptive GOP nominee for president, McCain — who leads a congressional delegation to Europe and the Middle East this week — has adopted a surprising diversity of views on foreign policy issues during his 25 years in Congress. It is a pattern that brings uncertainty to the path he would take if elected.

A “surprising diversity of views”? That’s charitable. One might also say he’s opportunistic and hypocritical. If you’re going to be an interventionist, you might as well be consistent. And if you’re going to claim that we can’t leave Iraq because it’ll plunge into violence, while omitting to mention that you supported “cutting and running” from Lebanon and Somalia (two of the world’s premier failed states), you have some questions to answer. I guess this inconsistency will give us something to look forward to regarding Iran, though. I’m sure the senator, who apparently understands foreign policy about as well as he understands economics, would be perfectly competent to open up yet a third front in the “Global War on Terror.”

Finally, McCain’s visit to Israel will underscore the absurdity of his desire to be a world leader. If Bill Clinton couldn’t solve the conflict, despite tremendous force of will, and Bush can’t solve the problem, despite slavish adherence to ideology, then how could McCain make any progress relying only on a borrowed ideology and a set of opportunistic policy positions? Inconsistency does not imply courage or creativity, the two traits that will be most necessary in a president who hopes to solve Israel/Palestine. McCain would flounder, potentially even more thoroughly than Bush has on the issue.

So let him trot around the world, raising money abroad because there’s none for him here. Maybe in McCain’s world, where riding by himself in a first-class train compartment makes him a “man of the people,” and shuffling through a Baghdad market with 100 armed guards and body armor gives him an insider’s view of the conflict, that’s enough to make him a world leader.

The Seminal News Feed

Warplanes, troops kill 40 militants in NW Pakistan
Thursday, 20 November 2008, 2:46 pm
ISLAMABAD, Nov 20 (Reuters) - Pakistani forces killed 40 Islamist fighters on Thursday as artillery and jet fighters backed ground troops fighting in the Bajaur tribal region, and an air strike hit mi. […]

Ukraine presses NATO, Russia seeks gas payment
Thursday, 20 November 2008, 2:43 pm
KIEV, Nov 20 (Reuters) - Ukrainian President Viktor Yushchenko, in comments published on Thursday, urged NATO to put his country on a fast track to membership as neighbouring Russia issued new demands. […]

UN peacekeepers needed in Somalia--African Union
Thursday, 20 November 2008, 2:32 pm
MOGADISHU, Nov 20 (Reuters) - The United Nations should send peacekeepers to Somalia urgently to stop the strife that is fuelling piracy and is being aggravated by feuding politicians, the African Uni. […]

DISCUSSION

4 RESPONSES to “McCain in Iraq”

Red Wind says  ::  March 16th, 2008 @ 10:52 pm EST

What are the FEC rules for fundraising abroad? Or the Senate ethics rules, for that matter?

Red Wind says  ::  March 21st, 2008 @ 11:37 am EST

Jonathan Singer has a bit more on the failure to reimburse for fundraising abroad:

http://www.mydd.com/story/2008/3/21/1648/10092

Of course, McCain has already broken FEC rules here at home:

http://www.americablog.com/2008/03/mccain-busts-fecs-spending-cap.html


LEAVE A COMMENT

Join the discussion! Get started by reading our Comment Policies.
YOUR COMMENT   (simple HTML is allowed)   Click to quote selected text
       

Take the Blog Reader Project survey.

UPCOMING ON REDDIT
Please vote!

UPCOMING ON DIGG
Please vote!
I support Health Care for America Now