So let me get this straight…you funnel money, including my tax dollars, to thugs and terrorists in Pakistan for decades, and then act surprised to discover some of it is going to the Taliban?
Don’t insult our intelligence.
The CIA is now pushing out into the open what we’ve known for some time - elements within the Pakistani ISI (the country’s equivalent of our CIA) are almost certainly aiding militants in Pakistan and Afghanistan. Via the New York Times we learn of a visit by the CIA to the ISI to confront them on the issue. But first the background:
The C.I.A. has depended heavily on the ISI for information about militants in Pakistan, despite longstanding concerns about divided loyalties within the Pakistani spy service, which had close relations with the Taliban in Afghanistan before the Sept. 11 attacks.
That ISI officers have maintained important ties to anti-American militants has been the subject of previous reports in The New York Times. But the C.I.A. and the Bush administration have generally sought to avoid criticism of Pakistan, which they regard as a crucial ally in the fight against terrorism.
[...]
The ISI has for decades maintained contacts with various militant groups in the tribal areas and elsewhere, both for gathering intelligence and as proxies to exert influence on neighboring India and Afghanistan. It is unclear whether the C.I.A. officials have concluded that contacts between the ISI and militant groups are blessed at the highest levels of Pakistan’s spy service and military, or are carried out by rogue elements of Pakistan’s security apparatus.
[...]
It was the ISI, backed by millions of covert dollars from the C.I.A., that ran arms to guerrillas fighting Soviet forces in Afghanistan in the 1980s. It is now American troops who are dying in Afghanistan, and intelligence officials believe those longstanding ties between Pakistani spies and militants may be part of an effort to destabilize Afghanistan.
How much more obvious can it get? We pumped money to militant Islamic groups in Afghanistan via the ISI in the 80s, and what did you think would happen…they’d just quit talking to each other? Thirty years may be too long for America’s collective memory to deal with, but in the march of history that’s a tiny sliver. People in their 30s during that time are now in their 60s. We can split hairs over whether it’s the ISI as an institution supporting the Taliban, or just elements within it, but at the level of cash flows it seems the case is closing that your tax dollars go from you to the administration to ISI personnel to the Taliban, all while our soldiers die in Afghanistan.
Those who have been watching us squander billions in Pakistan post-9/11 have also been screaming that the money isn’t all going to “fight terror”…some of it is going to fund terror. Or to fund Musharraf’s aggressions against India, as we saw last week when the administration offered him more money, and not even to “fight terror” but to boost his air force:
The Bush administration plans to shift nearly $230 million in aid to Pakistan from counterterrorism programs to upgrading that country’s aging F-16 attack planes, which Pakistan prizes more for their contribution to its military rivalry with India than for fighting insurgents along its Afghan border.
That our money is being wasted there has been clear for some time now. But now in another burst of intelligence we send spies to confront other spies openly? Aren’t spies supposed to operate on the down low? Meaning not only have we have wasted billions, we’re now causing a public relations disaster, as our embarrassment and their corruption gets splashed across the pages of newspapers around the world.
Al Jazeera gives us the Pakistani reaction:
Pakistan’s military has rejected as “malicious” a report that the CIA confronted Islamabad over allegations the country’s intelligence service was aiding al-Qaeda and Taliban fighters.
And the BBC has a little more:
Defence Minister Ahmed Mukhtar said members of Inter-Services Intelligence were accused of “tipping off” militants before strikes in the tribal areas.
Mr Mukhtar said that the Americans “mistrusted” the ISI.
His unusual public admission of the rebuke seems to mark a new low in ties between the US and Pakistan’s spies.
And all this goes down while Pakistani PM Gilani is in Washington meeting with the Bush administration. Great. Can a fake friendship get any faker? Can we manage regional complexities more foolishly? Obama can keep ramping up the “get the job done in Afghanistan” rhetoric if he wants, but he’s going to be dealing with one hell of a mess come January 2009.