Ruth Calvo

Loan Star State

by Ruth Calvo  ::  Filed Under U.S. Domestic Issues  ::  April 18th, 2009 @ 10:04 am EST

The events of teabaggage set off a lot of those indifferent to facts, chief among them being Texas’ governor Perry. Declaring that the Great State was not going to Take It anymore he harked back to our previous existence as a country and the myth that we could go there again without consequences.

A lot of folks who were listening remember that Texas has no state income tax and is a taker, not a giver, when it comes to federal funds. Our public services are not great even on the basis of milking the public outside the state.

Reality-based functionality has not been a characteristic distinguishing the right wing for a long time, but the flights of fancy have taken over their public statements since the 2008 election. Retreat from reality isn’t working out, though. Operating in fantasy land may get votes for those playing to the functionally challenged, but it isn’t making it any easier to operate a state.

Gov. Rick Perry appears to have given new life to the state’s two-decades-old tourism promotion – Texas: It’s like a whole other country.

The empathy Perry has shown this week to those spitting-mad-at-Washington secessionists had newscaster Geraldo Rivera calling him “grossly irresponsible” and ripe for impeachment, while former U.S. House Majority Leader Tom DeLay said that Perry was being a righteous governor “standing up for the sovereignty of his state.”

What is certain is that Perry has struck a chord. And it is aimed at Texas’ ultimate mythology – that because it began as a country, by gum, it could go it alone again.

Unlike Texas, said state Rep. David Swinford, “other states know they don’t have the right to secede. But that has been built into the Texas fabric, so we have the right to talk about it.”

A poll of 500 Texans released Friday showed that 31 percent believe (incorrectly) the state retains the right to form an independent country. And another 18 percent said, given the opportunity, they would vote for Texas to secede.

The fact is, the treaty under which Texas joined the U.S. provides that it could be divided into five separate states. But it is not empowered to leave the union, a question that the Civil War seems to have settled once and for all.

Perry has expressed bewilderment that his statements drew so much attention. And he did not, as some national media reports said, advocate secession. He did, however, assert Texas’ right to leave the U.S., and he expressed sympathy for those so frustrated with the federal government’s taxes, spending and mandates that they feel secession is an option.
(snip)
“Real leaders work to solve problems, but when Rick Perry fans the flames of frustration like a right-wing talk show host, he becomes part of the problem,” said state Democratic Party Chairman Boyd Richie.

Richie and others said that Perry is targeting a narrow base of enflamed Republican voters while preparing to run against U.S. Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison in the 2010 Republican governor’s primary.

“Clearly, he’s playing their song,” said political consultant Bill Miller. “And he was tone-perfect actually, for that group.”

Appealing to state residents who are feeling alienated from the country, as it receives control from public interest representatives for a change, is nothing new here in flyover country. Nothing like aggressive ignorance to set off its constituency. The fact is, though, that rightwing propaganda doesn’t benefit the state, either. Voting in public officials who despise the public has worked against the country for the past entire maladministration, and it will take a long time to dig back out of the morass they’ve made with a government opposed to the governed.

This should be a really good example for voters of what kind of service Perry exemplifies. We’ve had enough of lies and false claims.

Can we have a responsible official in the next election, please? On the right, there haven’t been any yet.

(This post also at http://cabdrollery.blogspot.com/ )

The Seminal News Feed

FACTBOX-Countries slap bans on pork after flu outbreak
Monday, 4 May 2009, 7:35 pm

Albanian immigrants get life in plot to hit US base
Tuesday, 28 April 2009, 9:26 pm

Six tonne drug blaze a small step in Afghan battles
Sunday, 26 April 2009, 11:50 am

DISCUSSION

6 RESPONSES to “Loan Star State”

Scott says  ::  April 23rd, 2009 @ 11:50 am EST

What is your source for claiming that Texas brings in more federal dollars than it puts in? According the taxfoundation.org, Texas gets $.94 for every $1 it pays.

Don’t let facts get in your way though.

http://www.taxfoundation.org/research/show/266.html

    Jason Rosenbaum says  ::  April 23rd, 2009 @ 12:13 pm EST

    That data is from 2005. When you add in spending for things like Hurricane Rita, plus factor in how the economic recession has worked, the numbers changed. I definitely saw updated numbers somewhere, but haven’t been able to find a link for you yet…

      Scott says  ::  April 23rd, 2009 @ 2:04 pm EST

      So a short term expenditure for a natural disaster that significantly impacted the energy economy for the entire country is your justification. Admit that it is an outright manipulation of information to support your point. Texas has one of the strongest economies during this economic crisis, if anything we will be paying in even more federal taxes than we get back this year.

      I will agree that Rick Perry’s secession speech was plain stupid, but your fantasy that Texas is a welfare state is full on retard.

      ken says  ::  April 23rd, 2009 @ 2:34 pm EST

      moreover, texas NOTE ONCE between 1981 and 2005 received more than we paid out.

      http://www.taxfoundation.org/research/show/22685.html

      ken says  ::  April 23rd, 2009 @ 2:35 pm EST

      damn my typing today is pathetic…

ken says  ::  April 23rd, 2009 @ 1:06 pm EST

i hate rick perry. i have never voted for him nor will i ever vote for him. he’s a bushite republican crony at best. however, i think you are a bit short-sighted in your commentary. i do not support secession at this time, but i do feel the need to defend your lack of research.

by the way, seceding by the very definition cannot be made truly illegal. nations declare independence from their parent countries because of the very laws, it’s silly to say that they do not “have the right”. did the united states have the right to secede from great britain? sure they did, and with french assistance they affirmed that right.

texas has a balanced budget, utilizes a fair simple consumption tax / property tax system, and as pointed out, pays out more than it receives. it also has 12th ranked economy in the world…not in the us, but in the world…

texas also posted “the only statistically significant increase in employment in 2008 with 153,700 new jobs”. http://www.texaswideopenforbusiness.com/assets/documents/Texas-Economi c-Overview.pdf

it is also the nation’s number one exporter.

i think we would be okay.

Comments are closed

Take the Blog Reader Project survey.

UPCOMING ON REDDIT
Please vote!

UPCOMING ON DIGG
Please vote!
I support Health Care for America Now